Wyse Guys Pizzeria

4.4 (176 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in
Lunch
+(11)

About Wyse Guys Pizzeria

Welcome to Wyse Guys Pizzeria, a beloved spot located in Montpelier, OH. Known for its friendly atmosphere and attentive service, this pizzeria offers more than just pizza. Customers rave about the outstanding subs, especially the Heavyweight, loaded with toppings, and the crispy chicken chunks. While opinions on the pizza crust vary, the vibe is undeniably inviting, featuring sports decor and classic pinball machines. With a strong commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Wyse Guys serves up a delightful dining experience that leaves patrons eager to return for more delicious offerings. Whether you’re in the mood for breadsticks or subs, this pizzeria has you covered!

Reviews (176) 4.4

  • Tom Stoyk
    Jul 22,2025

    So happy with my experience The atmosphere was very friendly and welcoming. The Pizza was amazing. It even passed the dad has to eat cold Pizza because he has a 3-year-old test. I know I'm going to get shredded in the comments for that one. But oh well yeah dad life

  • Emily Emens
    Jul 22,2025

    I am absolutely obsessed with Wyse Guys breadsticks and cheese-bread with marinara sauce. When I think of cheese-bread or breadsticks, I think of Wyse Guys. We’ve had the best service each time we’ve ordered from here and they’ve gotten our orders right every time. The food is hot and fresh and we’ve had no complaints! Their subs are really good, especially if you like bread. I recommend ordering the Heavyweight sub because it has so much on it and it tastes so good! I add banana peppers and black olives and it’s dynamite. The chicken parm sub was good, but I definitely think the bread to toppings ratio is uneven. Maybe add some veggies or extra chicken? Get their chicken chunks! They are sooooo good and crispy! Update: we tried the pizza for the first time. Not a fan. The crust was like cardboard and just kinda blah for us. The subs, garlic cheese bread, and chicken chunks are the way to go. Note: they have 2 kinds of garlic bread. The kind you want is like a pizza, not the kind you buy at the store to go with your spaghetti lol.

  • Lyndsey Stewart
    Jul 22,2025

    Came in for Chicken wings and was not disappointed! Love the atmosphere and food was excellent. Our server was energetic and absolutely adorable! Will be coming back soon.

  • Dean Stobinski
    Jul 22,2025

    Nice place. One of the few pizza places you can actually sit down inside and eat. Didn't get the pizzas. Did order a 12 inch sub. Came out perfect. Plus it wasn't super expensive. Definitely stop in. Place was very clean. Staff was very friendly and helpful.

  • Adam Roby
    Jul 22,2025

    Id never been and this is a great local place. Traveling through and really didn't want fastfood. Decor is fun for sports fans, they have at least 2 dozen sparkling pinball machines that worked (seemingly a rarity in arcades now). And they do have a change machine ($1 for games). The bread sticks were great. The two topping pizza was great. Fountain for your own drink refills close to you. Friendly service and fast. Bathrooms leave some room for desire but its an older building so it is what it is. Highly recommend!

  • Toby Hutchison
    Jul 22,2025

    Excellent place. Pizza is the best around. Owners take much pride in their long-standing business. Offer a variety of food.

  • Michelle Koppenhofer
    Jul 22,2025

    The Pizza was good, the Salad was good. The price for everything was not worth what we got. Plus I had pizza somewhere else that was better tasting.

  • Olivia Baker
    Jul 22,2025

    Great food for the cost. Great decor, clean, roomy booths. The employee was fast and kind. I'd definitely eat here again.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are the most popular dishes at Wyse Guys Pizzeria?

    Many customers rave about the breadsticks, cheese-bread, and subs, especially the Heavyweight sub. While opinions on the pizza vary, the chicken chunks are also highly recommended!

  • Can I make a reservation or is it walk-in only?

    You can make reservations at Wyse Guys Pizzeria, but they also welcome walk-ins, so you have flexibility no matter your preference.

  • What dining options are available?

    Wyse Guys Pizzeria offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery, making it convenient for any dining preference, whether you want to eat in or enjoy your meal at home.

  • What is the atmosphere like, and when is the best time to visit?

    The atmosphere at Wyse Guys is casual and cozy, perfect for groups or solo dining. It's typically lively in the evenings, so visiting earlier for a quieter experience might be a good idea.

  • What amenities does Wyse Guys Pizzeria offer for guests?

    They have wheelchair accessible seating and restrooms, free parking, and accept various payment methods including credit and debit cards, making it convenient for all guests.

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
Wyse Guys Restaurant & Pizzeria

110 W Jackson St, West Unity, OH 43570, United States

Pizza restaurant
G5 Pizza & Wings

17 N Xenia Dr, Enon, OH 45323, United States

Pizza restaurant
Keck's Pies and Pints

6735 W Pike, Zanesville, OH 43701, United States

Pizza restaurant
Don's Pizza

617 S Broadway St, Greenville, OH 45331, United States

Pizza restaurant
Pint & Pie Works

1925 N Cleveland Massillon Rd, Akron, OH 44333, United States

Pizza restaurant
A Gild Pizza/ Big Dzz House Bbq and More

1064 Tallmadge Rd, Kent, OH 44240, United States

Pizza restaurant
Fire And Stone Pizzeria

98 N Paint St, Chillicothe, OH 45601, United States

Pizza restaurant
Wauseon Rollercade

340 W Leggett St, Wauseon, OH 43567, United States

Pizza restaurant
Bella's Pizza

3858 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43228, United States

Pizza restaurant
Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop

223 Broad St, Conneaut, OH 44030, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page